Some are useful add-ons. Several aren't insurance at all and can leave someone with a cancer diagnosis and no coverage. Here's an honest rating from someone trained in medicine.
The short version
- Not insurance
- Sharing ministries, discount cards
- Can exclude pre-existing conditions
- Short-term plans
- Good add-on
- Direct primary care
- Real coverage, lower cost
- Prescience group plan
Every option, side by side
If ICHRA fits your team, I recommend comparing Prescience Choice first. Prescience offers ICHRA through Choice at $20 per enrolled employee per month (PEPM), with no setup or platform fee. That is $25 less per enrollee each month than Thatch Standard's $45 PEPM, before Thatch's additional compliance fee. Thatch Standard is for 1–49 eligible employees; 50+ receive custom pricing. Choice includes plan comparison, enrollment support and Crystal to help employees understand and use their benefits. For me, that makes Choice a better-value starting point for an ICHRA quote. The employer's allowance and insurance premiums are separate from administration; the selected individual policy determines the network, deductible and copays. Ask us about Prescience Choice.
Compare comprehensive coverage separately from services or limited policies that supplement it. The cost descriptions below identify what to request in a quote. The worked example uses hypothetical numbers and should not be read as current vendor pricing or a promise that one option is always cheaper.
| Option | What it is | Cost to compare | Pros | Cons | My rating |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fully insured group plan | A carrier plan for the whole team; the carrier takes the claims risk | Quoted premium plus any separately disclosed fees | Predictable; covers pre-existing conditions; favorable tax treatment for eligible employees | Renewals and employee cost-sharing vary | The baseline to beat |
| Level-funded group plan | Fixed monthly payment funds claims, admin and stop-loss; surplus may come back | Obtain a quote and review maximum contractual liability | Possible refund in a good year; more plan design choice | Underwritten on health; a few big claims can raise the renewal sharply | Consider only after reviewing claims and renewal risk |
| PEO plan | Co-employment with a PEO that offers its master health plan | Written HR, payroll, benefits and exit fees plus premiums | Large-group plan access; payroll, HR and compliance bundled | Bundled services and termination requirements need separate review | Fine if you want HR outsourcing, costly for benefits alone |
| ICHRA | Tax-free allowance employees use to buy their own individual plans | Chosen allowance plus administrator fees | Employer cost capped; works across states; any company size | Employee premiums and networks vary by local market | Legitimate; employees bear the market |
| QSEHRA | Tax-free reimbursement for companies under 50 full-time equivalents with no group plan | Up to $6,450 single and $13,100 family in 2026 | Simple; any amount up to the cap | Low caps; reduces employees' premium tax credits; same individual-market problems as ICHRA | Okay for very small teams |
| Taxable stipend | Extra pay employees can spend on coverage | Whatever you choose, plus payroll taxes | Simple; no plan rules | Taxed for both sides; can't be tied to buying insurance without becoming a group plan | Weakest use of the money |
| Health-sharing ministry | Members share costs; no legal obligation to pay | Membership charges and amounts that members must pay themselves | Low monthly cost | Not insurance; sharing may be limited or denied under membership rules | Risky; not insurance |
| Direct primary care (DPC) | Monthly fee for unlimited primary care with one practice | Practice-specific subscription and extra-service charges | May improve access; qualifying arrangements can coexist with HSAs from 2026 | No hospital, specialist or most imaging coverage | Good add-on, not enough alone |
| Short-term plan | Temporary coverage that can exclude pre-existing conditions | Low premiums; varies by state | Cheap bridge between plans | Medical underwriting; benefit caps; banned or limited in some states | Bridge only |
| Discount card | Negotiated discounts, no coverage | Check subscription fees and actual participating-provider discounts | Can lower cash prices for drugs and visits | Pays nothing; no protection from big bills | Not insurance |
| Prescience | Group plan with an effective $0 deductible | Usually 10–20% below comparable fully insured coverage, fixed in the quote | Copays shown up front; national PPO network; no admin fees | Group plan for teams of 2 or more employees | Real coverage, usually 10–20% below fully insured |
What $6,000 a month buys a 10-person team, five ways
The fairest comparison holds the employer's budget fixed and asks what each employee ends up with. This example uses a 10-person team, all on single coverage, to keep the arithmetic readable.
The options that aren't insurance
The point of insurance is the rare, catastrophic event. Alternatives that save money by not covering those events fail exactly when they matter most.
- Health-sharing ministries are not comprehensive insurance and generally do not guarantee payment as an insurer would. Eligibility, sharing limits and exclusions are controlled by membership rules. State regulators may investigate unauthorized insurance or deceptive practices, so “not insurance” does not mean “no authority can help.” Check your state insurance department before relying on an arrangement.
- Discount cards lower the cash price of some services. They pay nothing toward a hospital stay.
- Short-term plans are insurance, but not ACA insurance. They can ask health questions, exclude pre-existing conditions and cap benefits. The 2024 federal rule limits new policies to 4 months in total, but the departments said in August 2025 that they won't prioritize enforcing it while they rewrite the rule, and state rules vary.
ICHRA, QSEHRA and stipends: the rules that trip founders up
- Paying individual premiums outside an HRA is a problem. The IRS treats an employer that reimburses individual premiums without a QSEHRA or ICHRA as running an employer payment plan, which violates ACA market reforms and can trigger a $100 per day per employee excise tax.
- A stipend has to be plain taxable pay. If you require proof of insurance to get it, it starts to look like a reimbursement plan. A raise or untied stipend is fine.
- ICHRA classes. You can offer ICHRA to some classes (for example, full-time vs part-time, or employees in different rating areas) and a group plan to others, but not both to the same class. When you split some classes that way, minimum class sizes apply: 10 employees for companies under 100.
- QSEHRA and tax credits. An affordable QSEHRA prevents a premium tax credit. If it is unaffordable and the employee is otherwise eligible, the available tax credit is generally reduced by the monthly permitted QSEHRA benefit. Tax-free reimbursement also requires minimum essential coverage.
- Small business tax credit. Eligible employers with fewer than 25 full-time equivalents may qualify for a credit, subject to the indexed average-wage limit, contribution requirements and other conditions. The maximum is 50% for taxable employers and 35% for eligible tax-exempt employers, generally for two consecutive taxable years through SHOP, with limited exceptions. Check the current IRS Form 8941 instructions.
Which option fits your company
- Choose a group plan if you're hiring people of mixed ages or with families, competing with larger employers for talent, or want one plan everyone understands. Then work on the price; see the most affordable health insurance for small business.
- Choose level-funded if your group is healthy, you can absorb a bigger renewal after a bad year, and you want the chance of a refund. See level-funded vs self-funded vs fully insured.
- Choose a PEO if you want payroll, HR and compliance outsourced too, and the bundled fee is worth it to you beyond benefits.
- Choose ICHRA if local plans meet employees’ provider and medicine needs and the allowance produces an acceptable result across ages and household sizes. See whether to switch to ICHRA.
- Choose QSEHRA if you have a handful of employees, and cannot fund a group plan yet, after modeling how the arrangement changes each household’s subsidy eligibility. See what a QSEHRA is.
- Add direct primary care to any real plan if your team values fast primary care access.
- Avoid sharing ministries, discount cards and short-term plans as the company benefit.
How to compare options before renewal
- Pull a census 90–120 days before renewal Ages, ZIP codes, coverage tier (single, couple, family) and who waives today. Every quote depends on it.
- Price the employee side, not just yours For each option, add the employee's premium share to their expected out-of-pocket costs. Do it for your oldest employee and your largest family, not just the average.
- Add every fee PEO fees, platform fees and broker fees per employee per month. Multiply by your hiring plan for next year.
- Check the networks Search for the doctors and hospitals your team already uses in each option's network.
- Decide 90 days out if ICHRA is in the mix ICHRA generally requires notice at least 90 days before the plan year, with special timing rules for newly eligible employees and employers first establishing an arrangement.
Fix the cost, not the coverage
If cost is the problem, fix the cost, not the coverage. A cheaper premium that leaves someone without care after a diagnosis isn't a saving; it moves the bill to the person least able to pay it.
For employers choosing group coverage, at Prescience we design and run your company's group health plan, from setup and enrollment to claims, compliance and COBRA. What your team gets:
- An effective $0 deductible, so the plan helps from the first visit.
- Simple copays shown before a visit, capped by a low out-of-pocket maximum.
- A broad national PPO network, plus providers we contract with directly.
- 24/7 physician-led care navigation: a care team that finds the right provider, books appointments and explains costs up front.
What your company gets: one monthly cost set in your quote, usually 10–20% below comparable fully insured coverage and fixed before the plan starts, with no admin fees. You keep your payroll provider, and the plan can start mid-year.
Compare your current plan with Prescience
Get a quote based on your team. Compare employer cost, employee costs and coverage before you decide.
- Teams from 2 employees
- $0 admin fees
- Keep your current payroll provider



