Project the book
Revenue from groups that renew with you.
Commission on a percentage grows with premium.
Your own assumption; buyers price retention, growth and size.
Read: broker commission versus fixed fees
Read the guideEnter the book's annual commission and fee revenue, the number of client groups, the share of revenue that renews each year, the premium trend you expect and a revenue multiple. The default is a $420,000 book across 60 groups with 90% retention, 6% premium trend and a 2x multiple. The projection is the current book only, with no new business, so you can see what the book does on its own.
Nothing you enter leaves the browser.
A benefits book is recurring revenue that renews with retention and grows with premium. Enter the book's annual revenue, the number of client groups, retention, premium trend and a revenue multiple, and see what a client is worth, what the current book earns over five years and how much one point of retention changes it.
- Revenue driver
- Premium × commission, or fees
- Biggest lever
- Client retention
- Average revenue life
- 1 ÷ (1 − retention)
- Ownership
- Agent of record and carrier contracts
How the projection works
- Revenue per group is the book's revenue divided by its groups. A book with a few large clients and many small ones has a very different risk than the average suggests; check the largest ten clients' share separately.
- Retention is the share of revenue that renews with you each year. A group that moves to another broker with an agent of record letter takes its commission with it from the effective date.
- Trend grows the revenue that stays. Percentage commissions rise with premium, so a 6% premium increase is a 6% raise on that client. Flat per-employee fees don't move with premium; set trend to the growth in enrolled employees for a fee-based book.
- Average revenue life is one divided by the share of revenue lost each year: at 90% revenue retention, a dollar of today's revenue lasts ten years on average. It is a revenue figure, not how long clients stay; a client that stays but moves to a lower fee shortens it.
- Client value adds a client's revenue over 20 years, shrinking each year by retention and growing by trend.
The yearly projection multiplies the book by retention times one plus trend each year. When that product is above one, the book grows on its own; below one, it shrinks without new business.
A worked book
That is why buyers of agencies ask about retention before anything else. Revenue that renews is what they are paying for, and a multiple on a shrinking book is worth less than the same multiple on a growing one.
What moves retention
- The renewal meeting. Clients leave after a renewal they didn't understand. Showing the dollars, the employer and employee split and an alternative, early, keeps the decision with you. Our broker renewal calculator is built for that meeting.
- Service between renewals. Enrollment changes, claims problems and COBRA questions are where a client decides whether you are worth the commission.
- Transparency on compensation. Since 2022, brokers must disclose expected compensation to ERISA group health plans in advance. A client who learns your commission from a competitor is a client at risk.
- Having more than one answer. A broker who can bring a fixed-cost quote, a level-funded option or an ICHRA keeps the client when the incumbent carrier's renewal is bad.
Valuing a book
Agency transactions are commonly described as a multiple of recurring revenue or of earnings. The multiple depends on retention, growth, client concentration, the mix of commission and fee revenue, the carriers involved and how much of the relationship depends on one person. The calculator takes the multiple as your assumption; it does not estimate one.
What you own matters as much as what it earns. Commissions are paid under your carrier contracts while you are the agent of record, and an employer can change its broker at any time. Some carrier contracts vest renewal commissions to the agent after the contract ends and many do not. Read your contracts before you put a value on a book.
Commission and fee books behave differently
A commission book grows with premium trend, which has run well above inflation for years. A fee book grows only when the employer agrees to a higher fee or adds employees. Commission books therefore look better in a projection, but a client who sees the commission rising with every renewal is more likely to ask for a fee instead.
Our guide to broker commission versus fixed fees and the broker commission calculator cover that choice for a single client.
Measuring retention correctly
Retention is the most important number in the calculator and the easiest to misstate. Measure it the way a buyer or a lender will:
- By revenue, not by count. Losing one 200-employee client is not the same as losing one 3-employee client.
- Before premium growth. Separate revenue lost from clients who left from revenue gained because premiums rose, so trend doesn't hide attrition.
- Including downgrades. A client that stays but moves from commission to a lower fee, or drops a line of coverage, is partial attrition.
- Excluding new business. New clients belong in a growth figure, not in retention.
Measured this way, a book that looks like 95% client retention can be 88% revenue retention, because the clients that left were larger than average or the ones that stayed moved to fees. The calculator should use the revenue figure.
Track it every year with the same definition. A single year can be distorted by one large client, so look at a three-year average as well, and note the reason each lost client left: price, service, an acquisition, or a client that closed. Only the first two are yours to fix.
Retention also tells you where to spend time. If most lost revenue came from clients who left on price after a large renewal, the fix is an earlier renewal process with an alternative ready. If it came from service complaints, the fix is staffing or tools between renewals. Either way, a broker who measures retention honestly every year can plan growth on the book that actually stays, instead of on a number that only looks good in a pitch deck.
What this calculator leaves out
It projects revenue, not profit. Servicing costs, staff, licensing and errors and omissions coverage come out of the revenue before anything is earned. It also leaves out new business, bonus and override income from carriers, and the timing of commission payments, which carriers pay monthly as premium is received.
Retention and trend are averages. One large client leaving moves a small book much more than the calculator's smooth curve suggests.
Compare options for your next client renewal
Create a broker account to quote a client with Prescience and compare their coverage options.


