Compare the employer's cost

The average across tiers, from the renewal or a quote.

A ceiling: unused allowance stays with the employer.

Prescience Choice is $20 per enrolled employee.

Confirm your email

Price the ICHRA side with Prescience Choice

Get an instant quote

Enter the employees, the group plan's average monthly premium per employee across tiers, and the share the employer pays. Then enter the ICHRA allowance per employee per month and the administrator's fee. The default is a 15-person group paying 75% of a $780 average premium against a $450 ICHRA allowance with a $20 fee.

The calculator runs in the browser and stores nothing.

The first question an employer asks about ICHRA is whether it costs less. Enter the group plan's premium and the employer's share, then an ICHRA allowance and the administrator's fee, and see the yearly difference and the allowance at which the two cost the employer the same.

ICHRA allowance
A ceiling, set by class
Allowance can vary by
Age (up to 3:1) and family size
2026 affordability
9.96% of household income
Prescience Choice fee
$20 per enrolled employee

How the two structures differ

Group plan and ICHRA, side by side
Group planICHRA
Who picks the planThe employer, for everyoneEach employee, from the individual market
Employer costA share of a premium that changes at renewalAn allowance the employer sets, up to which it reimburses
Participation minimumUsually 70%None
NetworksOne plan's networkEach employee's chosen plan; often narrower
Multi-state teamsHard to cover well in one planEach employee buys locally
Who owns the planThe employer's group policyThe employee's individual policy

An ICHRA is a reimbursement arrangement, not insurance. The employer sets a monthly allowance for each class of employee, each employee buys an individual plan, and the employer reimburses premiums, tax free, up to the allowance. Allowances must be the same within a class but can rise with age, up to three to one, and with family size.

A worked comparison

The employer cost is only half of the comparison. Before you present it, price the individual market for each employee's age and ZIP code at the allowance you are proposing. An allowance that saves the employer money but leaves older employees paying far more than they do today is a hard sale.

Affordability for larger employers

Employers with 50 or more full-time equivalents have to offer affordable coverage or risk the employer mandate penalty. For an ICHRA, affordability compares the employee's cost of the lowest-cost silver self-only plan in their area, after the allowance, with 9.96% of household income in 2026 (10.22% in 2027). Employers can use safe harbors based on wages, the federal poverty line or rate of pay, and can test against the employee's work location instead of home.

Smaller employers don't face the penalty, but affordability still matters to employees: an employee offered an affordable ICHRA can't claim a premium tax credit, while one offered an unaffordable ICHRA can decline it and may qualify for a subsidy. Our ICHRA affordability calculator runs the test.

When ICHRA is the better recommendation

  • Groups that can't meet participation. An ICHRA has no participation minimum.
  • Teams spread across states. Each employee buys a plan with local networks instead of one plan that fits the headquarters.
  • Employers that need a fixed budget. The allowance doesn't move at renewal unless the employer moves it.
  • Young, single-heavy groups. Individual premiums for younger employees are often well below a group plan's average premium.

It fits less well for groups with many older employees in high-cost areas, families that rely on a broad PPO network, or employees who value one plan everyone shares. A group plan and an ICHRA can be offered side by side to different classes, such as full-time employees in one state and remote employees elsewhere, though not both to the same class.

If you are unsure, price both for the same census. The calculator gives the employer's side; individual quotes for each employee give the other half, and together they make the recommendation easy to defend.

Setting the allowance

The allowance is the employer's main decision in an ICHRA, and it sets both the budget and how employees experience the change. Most employers start from one of three anchors:

  • Today's cost. Set the allowance near what the employer pays per employee for the group plan, here $585, so the change is about choice rather than savings.
  • The benchmark plan. Set it near the lowest-cost silver premium for a typical employee, which keeps the ICHRA affordable and covers a solid plan.
  • A budget. Start from the amount the company can spend and check what plans it buys in each employee's area.

Classes add flexibility. An employer can set different allowances for full-time and part-time employees, salaried and hourly staff, or employees in different rating areas, as long as each class is a permitted class and everyone in a class gets the same terms, apart from age and family size. Some classes have minimum sizes when an employer offers a group plan to other classes.

Then check the result for the people most likely to object: the oldest employees, employees in high-cost areas and employees with families. If the allowance leaves them paying much more than today, raise their allowance through an age-based or family-size design rather than raising everyone's.

Employees need help on day one. Individual plans have their own networks and formularies, and an employee who picks a plan without checking that their doctor is in network will blame the change. Plan comparison and enrollment support are part of the ICHRA's cost, and part of why administration fees exist.

Give the decision time. An existing employer must send the ICHRA notice to eligible employees at least 90 days before the plan year starts, and employees need the individual market's open enrollment or a special enrollment period to buy their plans. Moving a group plan to an ICHRA for January means deciding by early autumn, so start the comparison with the client's renewal, not after it.

What this calculator simplifies

It uses one allowance for everyone and one average group premium. A real ICHRA design usually varies the allowance by age or family size, and a group plan's cost depends on tier mix. It also counts the whole allowance as spent, which overstates the ICHRA's cost when employees choose cheaper plans.

It does not compare benefits. A group PPO and an individual-market HMO at the same price are not the same coverage. Put networks, deductibles and out-of-pocket maximums next to the cost before the client decides. Our guide to switching from a group plan to ICHRA covers the conversation.

Price an ICHRA for your team

Compare a monthly allowance and administration costs with Prescience Choice. Each employee chooses an individual plan.

Frequently asked

Sources

  1. CMS, Health Reimbursement Arrangements (ICHRA) overview
  2. HealthCare.gov, Individual coverage HRA
  3. Federal Register, 2019 final HRA integration rules
  4. IRS, Revenue Procedure 2025-25 (2026 affordability percentage)
  5. KFF, ACA insurers are raising premiums by an estimated 26% for 2026

Cite this page

Rishab Jain. "ICHRA vs group health insurance calculator." Prescience, November 15, 2026. https://www.getprescience.com/tools/ichra-vs-group-health-insurance-calculator

This page is general information, not legal or tax advice. Plan terms, prices and savings depend on your company, your quote and your plan documents, which control if they differ from this page.