That saves an employee in the 22% bracket roughly a third of every premium dollar, and can save the employer 7.65% FICA when the affected wages are below the Social Security wage base. It needs a written plan document adopted before the plan year, and almost every company that charges employees any premium should have one.

The short version

Law
Internal Revenue Code § 125
Employee saves
Income tax + FICA on premiums
Employer saves
Up to 7.65% FICA, depending on wages
Requires
A written plan document

How a Section 125 plan works

Normally, anything an employee could take as cash is taxable, even if they spend it on something else. Section 125 is the exception: it lets employees choose between cash pay and certain tax-free benefits without the choice itself making those benefits taxable. In practice:

  • Employees elect their premium contribution before the plan year (or when hired).
  • Payroll deducts it before federal income tax, Social Security and Medicare tax, and before state income tax in most states. The employer doesn't pay FICA or FUTA on those dollars either.
  • Elections are locked for the plan year except after qualifying events like marriage or a new child. See qualifying life events.

The simplest version is a premium-only plan (POP): the only choice is cash or paying your share of the health, dental and vision premiums pre-tax. Larger versions add flexible spending accounts and other benefits.

The plan document requirement

A cafeteria plan must be a written plan. Without a document in place, pre-tax deductions don't qualify, and every dollar employees ran through payroll as pre-tax becomes taxable wages, with back income tax withholding and FICA for both sides. The document must exist and be adopted before the elections it covers; it can't be written later to fix past payroll. It typically spells out:

  • Each benefit offered, and the plan year.
  • Who's eligible, and when new hires can join.
  • How and when employees elect, and what happens if they don't.
  • The maximum salary reduction allowed, for example the health FSA limit.
  • The mid-year events that allow election changes, and the use-or-lose or carryover rules for any FSA.

Most payroll providers, benefits platforms and brokers can provide a premium-only plan document, under their own service and pricing terms. Ask what adoption support and testing are included. Have the company adopt it formally (a board consent or owner resolution), give employees a summary, and keep it with your plan records.

What the tax savings actually look like

FUTA savings are usually zero. Federal unemployment tax is 0.6% (after the usual state credit) on only the first $7,000 of each employee's wages. Anyone earning well over $7,000 still hits that cap after the pre-tax deduction, so FUTA doesn't change. High earners save less FICA: Social Security tax (6.2%) applies only to wages up to $184,500 in 2026, so an employer generally saves only 1.45% Medicare tax when both pre- and post-reduction wages remain above the wage base. Employees may also save the 0.9% Additional Medicare Tax when applicable; that tax has no employer match. One minor trade-off: lower Social Security wages can very slightly reduce future Social Security benefits.

What can and can't run through a Section 125 plan

Common benefits under a cafeteria plan (IRS Publication 15-B, 2026)
BenefitAllowed?2026 limit or note
Employee share of group health, dental and vision premiumsYesNo dollar limit
Health flexible spending account (FSA)Yes$3,400 a year
Dependent care assistance (dependent care FSA)Yes$7,500 a year ($3,750 married filing separately), up from $5,000
Health savings account (HSA) contributionsYes, with an HSA-eligible plan$4,400 self-only, $8,750 family, including employer money
Group-term life insuranceYesTax-free up to $50,000 of coverage
Adoption assistanceYesSubject to the annual adoption limit
Marketplace (exchange) plan premiumsNo, for most employersUse an ICHRA instead
Long-term care insuranceNo
Gym memberships, commuter benefits, education, mealsNoSome have their own separate tax rules

The tax result also depends on who receives the benefit. Premiums for an eligible spouse or tax-dependent child may receive different treatment from coverage for a domestic partner who is not a tax dependent. Do not mark every dependent deduction pre-tax merely because the insurer accepts that dependent. HSA contributions also require individual eligibility, not just enrollment in a plan labeled HSA-compatible. An employee's spouse's general-purpose FSA can affect that eligibility.

Who can't participate

Only employees can participate. Sole proprietors, partners (including LLC members taxed as a partnership) and owners of more than 2% of an S corporation generally can't participate in a Section 125 plan. Family attribution rules extend the S corporation exclusion to a 2% shareholder's spouse, children, parents and grandchildren who work in the business.

  • C corporation founders who are employees can generally participate, subject to the plan and nondiscrimination rules.
  • S corporation owners over 2% get their health premiums paid by the company and reported in W-2 wages, then usually deduct them on their personal return as self-employed health insurance. Those premiums aren't subject to Social Security and Medicare tax when paid under a plan for employees.
  • A sole proprietor's spouse who is a genuine W-2 employee can participate.

Nondiscrimination testing

A cafeteria plan can't favor the people at the top. If it does, the plan survives but those people lose the tax break: they're taxed on the benefits they could have taken as cash. Three tests apply:

Section 125 nondiscrimination tests (2026 thresholds)
TestWhat it checksWho's protected against
EligibilityThe plan is open to a fair cross-section of employees, not just executivesOfficers, shareholders owning more than 5%, employees highly compensated under the applicable facts and circumstances, and their spouses or dependents; do not substitute a retirement-plan threshold automatically
Contributions and benefitsHighly compensated participants don't get more benefits or employer money, or use the plan moreSame group
Key employee concentrationKey employees get no more than 25% of all the plan's tax-free benefitsKey employees: officers paid over $235,000, 5% owners, and 1% owners paid over $150,000

How to set one up

  1. Pick the plan type A premium-only plan if employees just pay premiums. Add a health FSA or dependent care FSA if you want them.
  2. Get and adopt the plan document From your payroll provider, broker or a benefits vendor. Adopt it before the plan year or the first payroll with pre-tax deductions.
  3. Tell employees Give a summary of how it works and how to elect. Include it in your open enrollment materials.
  4. Set up payroll Mark premium deductions as Section 125 pre-tax so they're excluded from federal income tax, FICA and FUTA wages, and check your state's treatment.
  5. Collect elections every year Many plans let elections carry over automatically if the plan document says so.
  6. Test once a year and keep records Run the nondiscrimination tests, ideally before the plan year ends so you can correct course, and keep elections, change requests and test results.

Common Section 125 mistakes

  • Pre-tax deductions with no plan document. The most common one. Payroll was set to pre-tax by default and nobody adopted a plan. Fix it before the next plan year and talk to a tax adviser about past years.
  • Letting employees change elections whenever they ask. Mid-year changes without a permitted event put the plan's tax status at risk. Tie every change to an event and keep the proof.
  • Running a 2% S corporation owner's premiums pre-tax. They must be reported in W-2 wages instead.
  • Reimbursing individual policies through payroll. Paying or reimbursing employees' individual premiums outside an approved arrangement can trigger ACA penalties. See health insurance stipends.
  • Never testing. Small, founder-heavy companies are the most likely to fail the key employee test without knowing it.

With a Prescience plan

With Prescience, you keep your current payroll provider. If employees contribute toward coverage, adopt and administer the Section 125 document before taking qualifying deductions pre-tax. Confirm who supplies the document, updates payroll and conducts testing; retaining payroll software does not automatically complete those tasks.

Compare your current plan with Prescience

Get a quote based on your team. Compare employer cost, employee costs and coverage before you decide.

  • Teams from 2 employees
  • $0 admin fees
  • Keep your current payroll provider

Frequently asked

Sources

  1. IRS, FAQs for government entities regarding cafeteria plans (Section 125)
  2. IRS Publication 15-B (2026), Employer's Tax Guide to Fringe Benefits
  3. IRS Revenue Procedure 2025-32 (2026 inflation adjustments, including QSEHRA)
  4. 26 CFR § 1.125-4, Permitted election changes (cafeteria plans)
  5. Social Security Administration, Contribution and benefit base
  6. IRS Revenue Procedure 2025-19 (2026 HSA and HDHP limits)
  7. IRS, Employer health care arrangements (employer payment plans)
  8. IRS Publication 969, HSA eligibility

Cite this page

Aditya Jain, MD. "How do pre-tax health insurance deductions work?." Prescience, November 21, 2026. https://www.getprescience.com/guides/section-125-pre-tax-health-insurance

This page is general information, not legal or tax advice. Plan terms, prices and savings depend on your company, your quote and your plan documents, which control if they differ from this page.