Payday Payroll health insurance: brokerage, pricing and a different plan

Payday Payroll offers benefits brokerage alongside payroll; compare its proposal with Prescience Diamond if your team wants an effective $0 deductible while retaining Payday for pay processing. This page concerns Payday LLC at paydaypayroll.com in Virginia Beach, Virginia. Its benefits offer includes selecting coverage and connecting enrollment to payroll, rather than a published, universally priced Payday medical policy.

Researched guide · Updated

Leading carrier networks. Prescience benefits.

  • Blue Cross Blue Shield
  • UnitedHealthcare

Plans on Blue Cross Blue Shield and UnitedHealthcare networks where available. Your location, group eligibility and plan set the carrier in your quote.

My view
Compare the coverage before changing payroll
Company
Payday LLC, Virginia Beach, Virginia
Benefits role
Full-service employee benefit brokerage
Published medical price
No rate or enrollment minimum on reviewed pages

Export your census from Payday Payroll

We have not verified public export instructions for Payday Payroll. Ask your account administrator or provider support for an employee census CSV containing the fields below. You can also use our template.

Include all current W-2 employees, including people who may waive coverage. Identify owners and contractors separately.

Include these fields

  • First and last name, work email, date of birth, home ZIP code, and sex assigned at birth.
  • Employment type: W-2 employee, contractor, or owner.
  • Spouse and dependent details if you have them. You can review missing details in the quote flow.

Remove Social Security numbers, bank details, and compensation columns before uploading; they are not needed for this census. If your provider exports Excel, save the employee sheet as CSV UTF-8. Keep the column headers; Prescience maps the file and shows the employee details for your review.

Start your quote

Choose the CSV you exported from Payday Payroll, or start without a file. You’ll confirm company details and verify your account before we securely import your census.

Start your quote without a CSV

Create your account, then add and review employees in the census step.

The file stays in this tab until you import it; refreshing means selecting it again. Download our census CSV template

What Payday Payroll actually offers

Payday describes its benefits division as a full-service employee benefit brokerage. Its benefits page discusses strategy, implementation and continuing support, while its payroll page describes deductions, tax calculations, filings and labor cost reporting. Buying coverage through that benefits team is a separate service decision from paying employees through Payday. I would start by asking who issues the policy, which legal entity holds the contract and who is responsible for enrollment corrections.

The vendor advertises new-hire synchronization, electronic enrollment, payroll updates during qualifying life events and automated terminations and COBRA notifications. These are useful administration capabilities. They do not establish that every employer has those services enabled, or that an outside plan will use the same workflow. Request a demonstration using your current configuration rather than assuming a benefits brochure describes your account.

The address on the company site is 365 Edwin Drive in Virginia Beach. That matters because other firms use Payday in their names. A proposal from a different Payday business is not evidence of this company’s carriers, charges or service terms. Match the vendor name and domain on your invoice before applying this comparison.

Separate the health premium from the service bill

The reviewed Payday pages do not give a medical premium schedule, a carrier-specific participation minimum or a numerical payroll subscription price. The home page promises simple pricing, but that is not a published dollar amount. Ask for a proposal separating premiums, employer contributions, employee deductions and any brokerage or administration charges. Also ask whether retaining payroll while moving medical coverage changes your existing service fee.

The IRS explains that employer accident and health benefits generally receive different tax treatment from ordinary wages, subject to the applicable rules. Have the payroll specialist confirm each deduction’s tax coding and any owner exceptions. An employee contribution entered under the wrong code can distort take-home pay even when the premium amount is correct.

How to retain Payday and replace medical coverage

Prescience Diamond provides a company health plan with an effective $0 deductible, simple copays and physician-led care navigation available around the clock. Our quotes begin at two employees, and Prescience has no administration fees. A company can keep its payroll provider; Payday setup with our team is staff-assisted. We do not promise a Payday API connection or that its existing enrollment synchronization carries over.

  1. Request the right roster Ask your Payday contact for a current employee census for the applying employer, including people who might decline coverage. Confirm the fields needed before sending it through the secure upload.
  2. Document the benefits workflow Record whether Payday currently sends deductions from its benefits module, and identify the person who will maintain the replacement amounts. Have that person approve a dated change list.
  3. Reconcile the first pay run Confirm coverage has started, stop the old medical deduction at the agreed cutoff and compare the payroll preview with elections. Review employer contributions separately from amounts withheld from employees.

Keep the old coverage active until the replacement effective date is confirmed. Ask Payday whether dental, vision or other benefits share the same administration arrangement, so replacing medical does not unintentionally remove unrelated coverage. Put future hire and termination updates in a written responsibility list.

When Payday’s benefits service is worth keeping

I would stay with Payday’s brokerage when its renewal is competitive, the team’s providers remain accessible and its staff resolves enrollment problems quickly. The direct link between benefits and payroll can save meaningful work for an employer with little HR capacity. A different plan needs to justify both its clinical tradeoffs and the extra coordination required during implementation.

Compare the summary of benefits, provider access, prescriptions and employee cost exposure alongside the employer premium. A cheaper payroll subscription alone says little about the medical policy. If the proposed alternative does not improve the employee experience or total budget, preserving a well-functioning local relationship is a reasonable decision.

Prescience vs. your current health plan

Using Payday Payroll does not by itself determine your health coverage. Compare the plan you use today with Prescience Diamond and Prescience Choice using the same employee census, coverage date and employer contribution. Your current plan might be arranged through a broker, carrier or PEO; this comparison does not assume Payday Payroll sells insurance.

Health insurance options for a team using Payday Payroll
What changesPrescience DiamondPrescience ChoiceYour current health plan
How coverage worksA company health plan with an effective $0 deductible and Prescience care navigation, with benefits specified in your quote.An individual coverage HRA (ICHRA): the employer sets an allowance and employees choose their own individual health plans.Use your plan documents to identify the carrier coverage and any employer-funded benefits. A broker or payroll brand alone does not identify the plan.
Employee deductible and costsDesigned for an effective $0 deductible for covered care under the Diamond benefit terms. Review the quoted copays, coverage limits and eligibility requirements.Deductibles, copays and networks depend on each employee's selected individual plan. Compare the allowance with the premium and expected out-of-pocket costs.Compare employee premium contributions, deductible, copays and out-of-pocket maximum from the actual plan, including any employer HRA or HSA funding.
Doctors and prescriptionsCarrier network selected for your group, with options such as Blue Cross Blue Shield or UnitedHealthcare where available, plus the Prescience Network and Prescience Extended Network. Confirm the exact network, doctors and prescription coverage in your quote before switching.Employees compare the local individual plans available to them and check their own doctors and medications.Use the current carrier's provider directory and drug formulary as the baseline. Keeping a payroll platform does not guarantee keeping a network.
Employee supportPrescience provides care navigation and benefits support alongside the quoted health plan.Prescience helps employees compare plans, enroll and manage their health allowance. The selected insurer supplies the underlying coverage.Identify what your carrier, broker and benefits administrator each handle today, including help finding care and resolving benefit questions.
Employer budgetRequest a group-specific quote and compare the full annual employer cost, including the benefits and services in the proposal. Savings depend on the group and plan design.Budget for the employer allowance plus the administration fee in your proposal. Compare how the allowance works for employees in different locations.Add premiums, employer contributions, administration and any bundled service costs. Use the renewal offer, rather than last year's price, when comparing a renewal decision.
HR and payrollConfirm the workflow for retaining Payday Payroll, employee changes and approved deductions before launch.Confirm how allowance administration and any applicable deductions fit your Payday Payroll account.Document the existing enrollment and payroll process, plus any broker, PEO or service agreement that affects a change.

Tell us whether you want to keep Payday Payroll for your existing HR or payroll workflow. An outside health plan may require a separate enrollment and deduction process; account compatibility must be confirmed.

  1. Export your Payday Payroll census Use the instructions above and include all current W-2 employees, including people who may waive coverage. Identify owners and contractors separately.
  2. Upload the CSV and complete your quote request Select the file on this page, then complete company details and account verification. Review the imported employee information in the quote flow.
  3. Compare the actual offers Have your current plan summary, renewal pricing, employee contributions and must-keep doctors ready for the comparison. Use the same census and start date, then confirm coverage and payroll timing before making a change.

Upload your census to compare options. Read more about Prescience's employer benefits and pricing. Your written quote and plan documents determine the offered benefits and costs.

Sources

Facts about Payday Payroll come from these sources, checked on the date above. Plans, prices and features change; confirm current terms with Payday Payroll and the carrier.

Frequently asked

See all HR and payroll platforms

Product names and logos identify their platforms and belong to their owners; their use does not imply endorsement, certification or a partnership. Blue Cross and Blue Shield names and symbols are registered marks of the Blue Cross Blue Shield Association.