Administration support is different from insurance
ADP describes Comprehensive Services as modular outsourcing across HR, payroll, benefits administration and talent management. Its FAQ explicitly distinguishes the service from TotalSource: the business remains the sole employer of record, while TotalSource uses co-employment. That distinction affects a benefits change. An employer using Comprehensive Services should ask how a new plan fits its managed administration scope, rather than assuming that changing insurance necessarily requires leaving a PEO. Read the current agreement in case the company buys additional ADP services alongside it.
The Comprehensive Benefits component describes plan configuration, open enrollment support, carrier connections and eligibility reporting, carrier invoice communications, ACA filings and COBRA administration. These are administrative functions, not one medical policy with one premium or network. ADP separately describes insurance brokerage through ADPIA. Identify the current plan sponsor, insurer and broker, then distinguish their roles from the ADP professionals who maintain the benefit records. An administrator’s service contract is not the same document as the insurance contract.
Service scope, company size and medical pricing
The current FAQ describes support for small employers with 25 to 149 employees, midsized employers with 150 to 999 and enterprises with 1,000 or more. Those are service audience bands, not medical participation rules. The product page asks businesses to discuss pricing and does not publish a universal service amount or medical rate. Ask for an itemized proposal stating which functions are included, which require extra work and what changes when a different plan provider is appointed. Keep the insurer’s premium and employee contributions outside the managed-services fee.
For the coverage decision, inspect the Summary of Benefits and Coverage described by HealthCare.gov. Compare the actual proposed medical benefits and cost sharing, then verify provider access. ADP’s ability to reconcile a carrier invoice does not establish that a replacement plan covers an employee’s treatment. Have the benefits decision maker validate the medical tradeoffs while the administration team confirms what can be configured and supported.
Keep useful managed services with an independent plan
Prescience Diamond provides an effective $0 deductible, simple copays and 24/7 physician-led care navigation. We quote company plans starting with two employees and have no administration fees. Those plan terms are separate from ADP’s service-size audience and contract charges. If your employer wants to retain Comprehensive Services, ask ADP what portion of administration will remain and where Prescience will take responsibility, rather than assuming two teams should both run the same process.
- Prepare the current employee population Ask the authorized HR or ADP service team for a demographics export covering the applying employer and all eligible workers. Reconcile waivers, leaves and recent hires before requesting the medical comparison.
- Write down the operating responsibilities Confirm who owns enrollment, deduction entry, employee support, invoice reconciliation and notices after the change. Use ADP’s agreed scope rather than assigning work solely because a capability appears on a public product page.
- Coordinate the staff-assisted payroll handoff Our team works with the employer and authorized payroll service on approved amounts and timing. This is not an automatic Prescience-to-ADP connection; agree which existing workflow must be updated or retired.
- Validate before closing the transition Confirm coverage effective dates, inspect the first completed payroll and reconcile the medical invoice. Treat missing enrollees and incorrect employee contributions as separate issues with named owners.
The Department of Labor explains federal COBRA continuation rights and notice requirements. Existing continuation participants and former-plan records need explicit treatment in the service handoff. Ask the current administrator to confirm responsibility instead of assuming that a new insurer or continued ADP payroll automatically carries every administrative obligation forward.
When to retain the present plan and administration
I would leave the current arrangement intact when ADP’s team handles complex benefits work effectively and the medical renewal still fits employees and the company budget. Managed support can be especially valuable when HR lacks capacity for configurations, eligibility reconciliation and employee questions. Even if Prescience is competitive, keep the existing medical plan if its care access and costs work better after a full review. A modular service can also remain useful after a plan change, provided the responsibilities and service charges are agreed clearly.
Prescience vs. your current health plan
Using ADP Comprehensive Services does not by itself determine your health coverage. Compare the plan you use today with Prescience Diamond and Prescience Choice using the same employee census, coverage date and employer contribution. Your current plan might be arranged through a broker, carrier or PEO; this comparison does not assume ADP Comprehensive Services sells insurance.
| What changes | Prescience Diamond | Prescience Choice | Your current health plan |
|---|---|---|---|
| How coverage works | A company health plan with an effective $0 deductible and Prescience care navigation, with benefits specified in your quote. | An individual coverage HRA (ICHRA): the employer sets an allowance and employees choose their own individual health plans. | Use your plan documents to identify the carrier coverage and any employer-funded benefits. A broker or payroll brand alone does not identify the plan. |
| Employee deductible and costs | Designed for an effective $0 deductible for covered care under the Diamond benefit terms. Review the quoted copays, coverage limits and eligibility requirements. | Deductibles, copays and networks depend on each employee's selected individual plan. Compare the allowance with the premium and expected out-of-pocket costs. | Compare employee premium contributions, deductible, copays and out-of-pocket maximum from the actual plan, including any employer HRA or HSA funding. |
| Doctors and prescriptions | Carrier network selected for your group, with options such as Blue Cross Blue Shield or UnitedHealthcare where available, plus the Prescience Network and Prescience Extended Network. Confirm the exact network, doctors and prescription coverage in your quote before switching. | Employees compare the local individual plans available to them and check their own doctors and medications. | Use the current carrier's provider directory and drug formulary as the baseline. Keeping a payroll platform does not guarantee keeping a network. |
| Employee support | Prescience provides care navigation and benefits support alongside the quoted health plan. | Prescience helps employees compare plans, enroll and manage their health allowance. The selected insurer supplies the underlying coverage. | Identify what your carrier, broker and benefits administrator each handle today, including help finding care and resolving benefit questions. |
| Employer budget | Request a group-specific quote and compare the full annual employer cost, including the benefits and services in the proposal. Savings depend on the group and plan design. | Budget for the employer allowance plus the administration fee in your proposal. Compare how the allowance works for employees in different locations. | Add premiums, employer contributions, administration and any bundled service costs. Use the renewal offer, rather than last year's price, when comparing a renewal decision. |
| HR and payroll | Confirm the workflow for retaining ADP Comprehensive Services, employee changes and approved deductions before launch. | Confirm how allowance administration and any applicable deductions fit your ADP Comprehensive Services account. | Document the existing enrollment and payroll process, plus any broker, PEO or service agreement that affects a change. |
Tell us whether you want to keep ADP Comprehensive Services for your existing HR or payroll workflow. An outside health plan may require a separate enrollment and deduction process; account compatibility must be confirmed.
- Export your ADP Comprehensive Services census Use the instructions above and include all current W-2 employees, including people who may waive coverage. Identify owners and contractors separately.
- Upload the CSV and complete your quote request Select the file on this page, then complete company details and account verification. Review the imported employee information in the quote flow.
- Compare the actual offers Have your current plan summary, renewal pricing, employee contributions and must-keep doctors ready for the comparison. Use the same census and start date, then confirm coverage and payroll timing before making a change.
Upload your census to compare options. Read more about Prescience's employer benefits and pricing. Your written quote and plan documents determine the offered benefits and costs.
Sources
Facts about ADP Comprehensive Services come from these sources, checked on the date above. Plans, prices and features change; confirm current terms with ADP Comprehensive Services and the carrier.